How Can We Possibly Do Stewardship In This Busy Moment?

by Barbara Barron | Posted November 18th, 2026 | Subscribe to this newsletter

We’re coming to the end of the calendar year, and our plates are overflowing with to-dos, most of which fall into the “reminder” category: year-end giving (“don’t miss your opportunity to receive a tax receipt for 2026!”) or reminders for campaign pledge payments.

Essentially, all requests for gifts.

We all know that historically the weeks between Thanksgiving and New Year’s Eve are the most robust ones for charitable giving in the US. So, we do it.

(Side note: if you are sending appeals, focus on the power of gifts of stock. Especially right now. 2026 has seen big growth in the stock market. The impact on donors who give appreciated securities is huge. This is especially true for older donors. Grandparent appeals? Yes!) 

But what if we inserted some heartfelt stewardship at this time?

“Oh Barbara! Seriously!? Are you suggesting we ADD something to our plates right now?!”

I am. Hear me out.

Have you subscribed to this newsletter yet? It only takes a minute.

Let me make the case

What most of our families have gotten used to are the reminders and the asks. They are expecting that, maybe even bracing for it.

Many years ago, I moved the distribution date of our report of giving to Thanksgiving, when our donors were not expecting a thank you, but it sure felt spot on. Lots of my clients do that now. And it is especially effective when it is a true thank you and not a veiled ask. Meaning, no envelope enclosed. That’s a different animal. Not wrong. Just different.

But as things get hectic, how nice is it to receive a truly heartfelt expression of appreciation? And as busy as you (and your donors) are, imagine how an unexpected moment of gratitude will land even more. It doesn’t need to be elaborate. In fact, don’t overthink it or start to get too fancy — because then it’s likely you won’t actually do it.

Simple, it turns out, is not always easy. But still, I urge you to think simple and quick.

  • A note to a trustee who has been super supportive of your program.
  • A photo you grab of something happening in a program that a family cares deeply about and dashing it off with a one-liner.
  • A call to a loyal family (and leaving a message is actually perfectly fine and sometimes even better) saying you thought of them and wanted to say thanks again for their increased gift this year.
  • A text of the same ilk is also great.

The point here is, as I often say, to “surprise and delight”. If you can connect the dots, all the better:

“Jesse, you leapt to mind for me today because I know how deeply you care about our robotics team and they are loving the additional supplies your support made possible.”

“Morgan, were your ears burning this morning? My team was talking about you in our meeting. We are so grateful for your hard work this fall. Thank you!”

“Parker, the model UN team is on their way to the competition and your family’s support has helped make that possible. Thank you!” 

I often speak to groups at conferences about the importance of stewardship. How it is the always important but rarely urgent part of our work. I like to share the work of Penelope Burke of Cygnus Research. Her annual survey of donors of all stripes to all types of organizations remains steadfast in its outcome. Donors report at crazy-high percentages (like 85%) that if we do three things before we ask for another gift, they are likely to give again AND give more.

Those three things are embarrassingly simple:

Number One
Thank me right away.

Number Two
Thank me accurately (ouch!): spell my name correctly and be sure my gift date and amount are correct. Note if my gift was directed or restricted in any way. What was it for?

…and the game changer:

Number Three
Tell me what you did with my gift. Impact. Results. What difference did it make?

One more pro tip: don’t attempt to do this for everyone. That’s a trap that will paralyze you from doing it for anyone. Choose a handful of folks. Ask your team to generate a few names from their experience. They may know of some super worker bees you don’t. And maybe spread the love by asking each team member to do this, so it doesn’t all come from you.

Quick. Heartfelt. Go!

As always, and especially now, thank you for everything you’re doing.

Barbara Barron
[email protected]


Share this post:


BARBARA BARRON is one of the most respected and highly sought-after independent advancement professionals in the country, having worked with dozens of schools in every corner of the United States.

She has raised over $20 million for schools where she served as the Director of Development. Barbara is a New York Times bestselling author, speaker, and presenter who currently advises dozens of schools in various capacities. She is considered a thought leader in the world of advancement, with her writing widely shared by professionals in development offices worldwide.


More Advancement Articles